The first week of November was arguably one of the darkest in the life of CHADEMA chairperson Tundu Lissu. He lost his elder brother, veteran lawyer Alute Mughwai Lissu, on November 1. On November 6, he was cleared of treason but handed a four-year prison sentence for incitement, an offence that had not been separately charged.
He remained in prison despite asking to attend his brother’s funeral, adding another layer of grief to an already broken heart. If the two believed in reincarnation, one can only hope they will find each other again in another life.
Yet, amid such profound tragedy, history has a bittersweet souvenir reserved for Lissu and those of his kind.
From Robben Island in South Africa to James Fort Prison in Ghana; from the political prisons of communist Czechoslovakia and Poland to the detention cells of Côte d’Ivoire and Nyayo House torture chambers in Kenya, history has repeatedly produced political leaders whose struggles against established political systems preceded their rise to national leadership.
Throughout human history, our blue planet has seen great people become victims of their free thinking. From the times of Rome’s great lawyer and orator Marcus Tullius Cicero to Russia’s Alexei Navalny, free thinking and an appetite for order and justice have never been an easy path.
Nelson Mandela, Kwame Nkrumah, Laurent Gbagbo, Václav Havel and Lech Wałęsa, to name just a few, all experienced imprisonment before becoming heads of state. Raila Odinga followed a different trajectory, becoming prime minister in a 2008 power-sharing government and ending up as one of East Africa’s most consequential opposition leaders of all time.
READ MORE: Inside Tundu Lissu’s Two-Part Speech After His Guilty Verdict
While these stories cannot settle Lissu’s fate, they reveal an intriguing pattern that may suggest his political journey is unfinished and may eventually take a similar direction.
Prison to power
Nelson Mandela’s story remains perhaps the most remarkable of all. An anti-apartheid activist and leader of the African National Congress, Mandela was sentenced to life imprisonment in 1964 and spent 27 years behind bars. To the white minority leadership back then, that was it!
Mandela was done, and there would be peace on the streets—whatever peace meant! Little did the authorities know that the imprisonment strengthened the people’s resolve, leading to a tougher struggle that also attracted external pressure. He was released from prison in 1990.
Four years later, against all odds, Mandela became South Africa’s first democratically elected Black president. A brutal prison sentence failed to extinguish a political movement or its leader’s national significance.
Ghana’s Dr Kwame Nkrumah offers another fascinating example. Known by the Akan honorific Osagyefo, Nkrumah was arrested and imprisoned in 1950 following his non-violent Positive Action campaign against British colonial rule. However, his political movement continued to gain ground even in his absence.
His Convention People’s Party won the 1951 general election while he was still in prison, securing his release to lead the government as Leader of Government Business. He became prime minister in 1952, led Ghana to independence in 1957 and became president in 1960. His movement and determination survived the prison terms that he suffered.
READ MORE: The Road to November 6: Tundu Lissu’s Treason Trial in Dates
In more recent history lies Côte d’Ivoire’s Laurent Koudou Gbagbo. A post-independence university lecturer, historian and trade union activist, Gbagbo experienced imprisonment for what authorities described as subversive teaching, and later exile. On any other day, I would have likened this ‘crime’ to incitement.
He helped form the underground opposition that became the Ivorian Popular Front in 1982, went into exile in France, and later became a leading opposition figure, rising to the presidency in 2000.
His journey from imprisonment and exile to State House demonstrates how political fortunes can change dramatically. The kind of leader he would later become is debatable, but I would rather reserve that story for another day.
Different destinations
Europe offers two equally compelling examples. Václav Havel, a playwright and democracy activist in communist Czechoslovakia, spent about five years in prison across several periods for his dissident activities. He subsequently emerged as one of the leading figures of the 1989 Velvet Revolution and became president that December.
In Poland, Lech Wałęsa, a former electrician who emerged as the leading voice of Poland’s Solidarity labour movement, was detained during the communist regime’s crackdown on dissent. He later won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1983 and was elected president in 1990.
Closer to home, Raila Odinga’s story offers an important East African lesson. A fierce critic of Daniel arap Moi’s one-party government in Kenya, Raila endured unjustified treason charges and years of detention without trial, including nearly six years between 1982 and 1988. He was detained again for his pro-democracy activism and later went into exile.
READ MORE: Tundu Lissu Cleared of Treason But Jailed for Four Years for Incitement
He subsequently became one of Kenya’s most influential opposition leaders, contested the presidency five times and served as prime minister between 2008 and 2013. He never occupied State House, but his influence on Kenya’s democratic evolution was undeniable.
His death in October 2025 closed a remarkable political chapter, and he was accorded a state funeral with military honours.
These stories are not identical, nor do they suggest that imprisonment automatically produces presidents. Indeed, Raila’s experience reminds us that a lifetime of political struggle does not necessarily culminate in occupying the highest office.
Nonetheless, politically motivated arrests and imprisonment can increase popularity, following and political capital, sometimes opening a path to State House.
The Lissu question
From his activism as a lawyer and human-rights defender to his parliamentary career and leadership of CHADEMA, Lissu has become one of the most recognisable figures in Tanzania’s opposition politics.
His survival after being shot 16 times in the 2017 assassination attempt, and subsequent return to political life, gave his story an extraordinary dimension, and he doesn’t seem to slow down.
READ MORE: Alute Lissu, Veteran Constitutional Lawyer and Tundu Lissu’s Brother, Dies After Long Illness
His latest confrontation with the state and the controversial prison sentence have added another chapter. The verdict in particular has generated strong reactions. Bishop Benson Bagonza, one of the most outspoken clerics, has reportedly suggested that the handling of Lissu’s case does not advance reconciliation.
Even in the touching 2025 commentary described as a dirge, Bagonza was quoted as arguing that coercion had increased sympathy and support for Lissu; the commentator framed this as a warning about forging martyrs.
This raises an important observation: political persecution can work as a blessing in disguise, potentially strengthening the public standing of the very individual it seeks to marginalise.
Prominent advocate Peter Madeleka has also questioned the legal foundation of the judgment. During a press conference following the ruling, he argued that treason has no corresponding lesser offence and that section 319 of the Criminal Procedure Act could not properly be used to substitute it with incitement.
His interpretation adds to the legal debate surrounding the judgment, particularly whether Lissu had been afforded a proper opportunity to defend himself against the offence for which he was ultimately convicted. The court held that he had received notice and an opportunity to defend himself; Lissu has filed notice of appeal against his conviction and sentence.
The question, therefore, is not simply whether Lissu will emerge from prison; it is what happens to his political movement, his public standing and Tanzania’s democratic space during and after this period.
READ MORE: Tundu Lissu Closes Defence After Saying DCI Kingai Will Not Testify
Mandela eventually became president, Nkrumah led Ghana to independence, and Gbagbo rose from imprisonment and exile to State House. Havel and Wałęsa became presidents following democratic transformations, while Raila came close on many occasions but remained a formidable political figure without ever becoming president.
Lissu’s destination may be unknown for now, but history suggests that political imprisonment does not always write the final chapter of a politician’s career. Sometimes it opens a much higher door to greatness.
For Tanzania, the unfinished political journey of Tundu Lissu, now Inmate No. 623/2026, may yet become one of the defining questions of its democratic future. He embodies the democracy the country has sought to achieve since the return of multiparty politics in 1992 and may well be the ultimate symbol of national rejuvenation.
Festo Mulinda is a political analyst and freelance columnist focusing on international relations and geopolitics. He can be reached at mulindafesto@gmail.com or on X as @fmulinda_III. The opinions expressed here are the writer’s own and do not necessarily reflect those of The Chanzo. If you are interested in publishing in this space, please contact our editors at editor@thechanzo.com.