The Chanzo is hosting Digital Freedom and Innovation Day on April 20, 2024. Register Here

Samia Opens Reconciliation Talks, But CHADEMA Stays Away

The president consults party leaders on a proposed reconciliation commission, but CHADEMA insists justice, accountability and political freedoms must be addressed first.

subscribe to our newsletter!

Dar es Salaam – President Samia Suluhu Hassan has consulted political party leaders on forming a Reconciliation and Mediation Commission to pave the way for constitutional amendments, in a meeting that Tanzania’s main opposition party CHADEMA did not attend.

The November 16 meeting at the Dar es Salaam State House brought together members of the Council of Political Parties as part of consultations on national reconciliation. Council members proposed that the commission should represent the interests of both sides of the Union and ensure gender equality, according to the presidency’s statement.

The discussions placed constitutional changes alongside reconciliation, but did not produce an announced agreement with CHADEMA, which has previously set out objections to dialogue that leaves political freedoms, victims’ rights and accountability unresolved.

“It is now time to continue consultations with political stakeholders, civil institutions and the private sector to form a Reconciliation and Mediation Commission, which will coordinate preparations for the process of amending the Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania,” President Samia said in an X post.

Commission proposal

The presidency’s statement, signed by Director of Presidential Communications Bakari Machumu, said President Samia thanked the council and party leaders for their readiness to engage in discussions aimed at strengthening the nation’s foundations.

She also described the talks as productive in a separate message, saying they concerned the best way forward on reconciliation and, ultimately, constitutional amendments that would serve the country’s broader interests. She presented the engagement as part of efforts to strengthen unity, national cohesion and shared understanding on public affairs.

READ MORE: Inside Tundu Lissu’s Two-Part Speech After His Guilty Verdict

The commission remains a proposed body, rather than an institution whose membership and working arrangements have been announced. Its stated role would be to coordinate preparations for constitutional amendments, not to enact those changes itself.

The presidency said the meeting continued consultations with different stakeholders. President Samia had previously met presidential candidates and running mates from the 2025 general election, as well as political party leaders.

The invitation issued through the Registrar of Political Parties extended beyond council members. National chairpersons and secretaries-general of fully registered parties who were not council members were also invited to attend personally.

The council’s recommendation for representation from both parts of the Union and gender equality addresses the composition of the proposed body. The announcement did not explain how victims of violence, families of missing people or other affected communities would participate.

Conditions for dialogue

CHADEMA’s absence comes against a longstanding disagreement over the terms on which it would enter negotiations. In July, deputy chairperson John Heche said the party’s Central Committee required national chairperson Tundu Lissu’s release and the involvement of a mediator before talks could begin.

Heche said discussions about resolving the national crisis concerned citizens, not a handful of leaders, and should therefore take place openly. Party organs would also have to decide on participation. “There are no talks we will enter into without a mediator,” he said at the time.

READ MORE: CHADEMA Accuses Police of Torturing Detained Members, Denying Bail and Lawyers

Lissu’s legal position has since changed, but he has not secured release through those proceedings. On November 6, the High Court rejected the treason charge but convicted him of incitement and sentenced him to four years in prison.

He disputes the conviction and filed a notice of appeal on November 9. The notice challenges both conviction and sentence; it is not an order releasing him or overturning the judgment.

ACT Wazalendo’s participation brought one of the country’s two major opposition parties into the meeting, following its public insistence that reconciliation must address killings, disappearances and accountability. Its earlier position also called for a new constitution, rather than amendments to the existing document, a distinction from the process outlined by the presidency.

The party said the country faced a political crisis rooted in violations of democracy, good governance and human rights. It criticised the government’s response to the October 29, 2025 killings and alleged that the 2024 local elections and 2025 general election had been stolen.

“Who are we reconciling with, on what basis, and in whose interests?” its leaders asked.

ACT argued that reconciliation could not mean asking people to forget their suffering or shielding those responsible for crimes against civilians. It said the inquiries led by retired judges Mohamed Chande Othman and Shaban Ally Lila had not fully answered public demands for truth, justice and accountability.

READ MORE: Tanzania Defends Secrecy on Election Violence Report at UN Rights Review

“Reconciliation cannot be a means of making citizens forget their pain, erasing the memory of the blood that was shed, or granting immunity to those involved in crimes against civilians,” the party said.

ACT demanded an independent international commission to investigate killings, abductions and disappearances. It also called for the removal of the heads of intelligence, defence and police, alongside regional and district commissioners in areas where killings occurred, and legal action against those an independent investigation found responsible.

The party also wants a new constitution before 2029, rather than amendments to the existing document. That differs from the constitutional-amendment process described in the presidency’s announcement.

Truth and accountability

The dispute concerns both the political framework for talks and the response to the election violence. The Chande inquiry’s findings presented on April 23, recorded at least 518 deaths and more than 2,000 injuries, while cautioning that the death toll was not conclusive.

The Lila commission was subsequently established to investigate criminal responsibility, including the organisation of violence and allegations of excessive or unlawful force. That criminal inquiry is separate from the reconciliation commission President Samia now proposes.

The government has defended its approach, saying accountability must cover both those who organised violence and any unlawful use of force. At the November 5 UN rights review, Constitutional and Legal Affairs Minister Abdallah Ulega argued that prematurely publishing the full Chande report could compromise evidence, endanger witnesses and prejudice fair trials.

READ MORE: Kenya Police Chief Denies Holding Mwaipaya, But Court Still Has No Answer on Where He Is

Civil society has also pressed for results beyond dialogue. Seven organisations, including the Legal and Human Rights Centre, Tanganyika Law Society and Twaweza, used the first anniversary of the violence to demand support for victims, answers about missing people and a public timetable for implementing recommendations.

Their position was that reconciliation should not replace criminal accountability where evidence establishes offences. They called for inclusive national dialogue alongside constitutional and electoral reform.

Zanzibar’s experience

ACT has also participated in a separate reconciliation process in Zanzibar. A July agreement with CCM eventually led to ACT chairperson Othman Masoud Othman’s return as First Vice President in September, restoring the Government of National Unity.

At his swearing-in, Othman warned against treating that government as a mechanism for sharing posts, arguing that genuine reconciliation required truth and public participation. That arrangement concerns Zanzibar’s constitutional power-sharing framework, rather than the proposed national commission.

The national debate has likewise extended beyond negotiations among party leaders. In a February Kivulini Talks discussion that the Chanzo organised, participants questioned whether reconciliation could deliver lasting change without addressing the causes of conflict and including people affected by abuses.

For now, however, President Samia has announced further consultations, while council members have proposed principles for the commission’s composition. 

No commissioners, appointment date or constitutional proposals were announced, and the November 16 statement did not explain how the objections of the two absent opposition parties would be addressed.

Journalism in its raw form.

The Chanzo is supported by readers like you.

Support The Chanzo and get access to our amazing features.
Digital Freedom and Innovation Day
The Chanzo is hosting Digital Freedom and Innovation Day on Saturday April 20, 2024 at Makumbusho ya Taifa.

Register to secure your spot

Did you enjoy this article? Consider supporting us

The Chanzo is supported by readers like you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

×